A Feline Union explainer · Norway, 1940–1970

The Ration: what came back with the butter

Under the German occupation, Norwegians ate less fat, less meat and less of everything, and smoked less. Heart disease fell. After liberation the butter, cream, margarine and tobacco came back, and heart disease climbed for twenty years. So which was it: eating less, or eating differently?

Clots after surgery, Oslo32 → 6per 1,000 operations, before the war and during it. Back to 20 by 1947.
Heart attacks, Oslo men 40–594 → 16per 10,000 a year, from 1945 to 1950.
North Karelia, Finland−82%heart deaths in working-age men, early 1970s to 2012. No ration needed.
The question

Did the war save hearts by putting less on the plate, or by putting different things on it?

01 · Norway, 1940–1945

The dip

Germany occupied Norway in April 1940. Food went to the occupying army and to Germany, and what was left was rationed. Norwegians lived on coupons for five years.

In January 1951 two Oslo doctors, Axel Strøm and R. Adelsten Jensen, published what the death certificates showed. Deaths from diseases of the heart and circulation fell sharply during the occupation, especially deaths from blocked coronary arteries. After 1945 they rose again. Strøm put the fall down mainly to diet. Less smoking and more walking and physical work were named as possible contributors.

Mortality from circulatory diseases in Norway 1940–1945.

A. Strøm and R. A. Jensen, The Lancet, 20 January 1951

The paper became one of the founding exhibits of the idea that what we eat decides how our hearts fail. It is also weaker than it looks.

1941The year Norway changed how deaths were reported and what diseases were called. In 1990 a Bergen researcher, A. C. Gogstad, re-examined the wartime figures. The recorded decline began before the diet got worse, and the rise began before the diet got better. His verdict: the figures "may thus be due to artefacts."

So the death curve alone cannot carry the argument. Something measured another way has to. There is something.

02 · The plate

What changed on the table

The occupation did not starve Norway. It made it a little hungry and changed what was on the plate.

Four things moved at once: how much people ate, what they ate, how much they smoked, and how much they walked and worked. Any one of them could lower heart risk. The trick is pulling them apart.

03 · The clock

Faster than arteries heal

Strøm and Jensen had a second record, and it was not a death certificate. Oslo's hospitals counted how often patients developed blood clots after an operation. Change the coding rules on death certificates and this number does not move.

Blood clots after surgery, Oslo hospitals

Thromboembolic complications per 1,000 operations

Bar chart. Before the war, 32 clots per 1,000 operations. During the occupation, 6. In 1947, 20. 320 32 6 20 BeforeOccupation1947

Strøm and Jensen, Nordisk Hygienisk Tidsskrift, 1950, as reported by Pedersen, Tverdal and Kirkhus, Tidsskrift for Den norske legeforening, 2004.

Clotting dropped by four fifths during the war and climbed back within two years of peace. That is far too fast for clogged arteries to clear and refill. The Norwegian researchers drew the obvious conclusion: whatever changed, it acted on the blood's tendency to clot, not on the slow build-up in the artery wall.

In 1981 two Danish researchers, H. O. Bang and J. Dyerberg, the scientists who studied heart disease among Greenland's Inuit, offered a mechanism. Wartime Oslo ate less fat and more fish, and fish oil makes blood platelets less sticky. It was a hypothesis, not a wartime measurement. A trial later tested part of it.

29%Fewer deaths over two years among Welsh heart-attack survivors told to eat oily fish twice a week, in the Diet and Reinfarction Trial published in 1989. Advice to cut fat did not show the same benefit.

Smoking acts on the same fast pathway. Tobacco makes blood clot more readily, and Norway's tobacco fell by a third. A fast effect points to fast causes: fish, tobacco, blood pressure, a little less weight. Not years of arteries quietly healing.

04 · England and Wales, 1939–1945

Britain: rationed, not the same war

Britain rationed too: fat, sugar, meat, butter. If rationing alone protected hearts, Britain should show it. In 1986 two British epidemiologists, David Barker and Clive Osmond, checked.

After allowance for changes in the rules for coding cause of death, and for the sharp increase in all-causes mortality in 1940, there is little to suggest that time trends in CHD were much influenced by the war.

D. J. P. Barker and C. Osmond, Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health, 1986

Two things set Britain apart from Norway. Britain's rationing mostly evened out the classes rather than cutting everyone: working-class households went from 2,557 to 2,375 calories a day between 1936 and 1945, while middle-class households fell from 3,159 to 2,402.

5.4 → 7.2Cigarettes per adult per day in the United Kingdom, 1939 to 1945. Britain smoked a third more during the war. Norway smoked a third less.

Same ration book, opposite tobacco, no clear drop in heart deaths. That is what you would expect if the fast part of the Norwegian dip came from tobacco and the blood, not from the ration book itself.

05 · Denmark, 1917–1918

Copenhagen, 1917: the pigs went hungry

The experiment had been run once before. In the First World War, blockade cut Denmark off from imported grain and feed. Denmark's food adviser, Mikkel Hindhede, had the country's grain go to people instead of pigs and cattle. Barley and bran went into bread. Grain and potatoes were taken from the distillers, so no brandy was made, and beer output was halved.

−34%Deaths from all causes among Copenhagen men aged 25 to 65, from October 1917 to October 1918, compared with the years before. Across Denmark the death rate fell to 10.4 per 1,000, against a previous low of 12.5. Hindhede estimated 6,300 lives saved.

That is the most dramatic number in the story, and the least specific. It counts deaths from every cause, not heart disease. And Hindhede himself credited a large share of it to the beer and brandy that disappeared. Copenhagen shows that a forced change in diet can save lives quickly. It cannot tell you which change did it.

06 · The Netherlands, 1944–1945

The Hunger Winter: a different thing entirely

Less is not always better. In the winter of 1944 the Germans cut food to the western Netherlands. Official rations fell from about 1,400 calories a day in October 1944 to about 500 by January 1945. People ate sugar beets, potato peel and tulip bulbs, which a Dutch doctor declared fit to eat that year.

≈ 20,000Deaths from the famine, by the usual count. A 2017 study of national death records estimated about 23,000 excess deaths in the six largest western cities alone, between September 1944 and July 1945.

Children carried it for life. Among people born in Amsterdam after their mothers starved early in pregnancy, 8.8 percent had coronary heart disease by around age 50, against 3.2 percent of those not exposed. Starvation in the womb raised heart risk. It did not lower it.

Norway was mildly hungry. The Netherlands starved. Treat them as one experiment and you learn nothing. Moderate restriction and famine are different interventions with opposite results.

07 · Norway, 1945–1970

What came back

Liberation came in May 1945. Milk, cheese and eggs were off the ration by 1949; meat, coffee and sugar by 1952. Cigarettes came back. Then the fat came back, and kept coming.

Total calories recovered within a couple of years. What kept climbing for the next two decades was the fat, much of it hard margarine and dairy fat.

4 → 16Heart attacks per 10,000 Oslo men aged 40 to 59, each year, from 1945 to 1950. Four times as many in five years, as food and tobacco returned.
1966–70The peak. Deaths from coronary heart disease among Norwegians aged 40 to 69 were twice as high for men, and half as high again for women, as in the early 1950s. By then fat made up 41 percent of Norway's calories.

Then it reversed, without a war. From 1970 fat fell from 41 percent of calories to about 34, cholesterol fell, men smoked less, blood pressure came down and treatment improved. Norway's coronary death rate more than halved. Compared with the rates of the early 1970s, that is about 6,180 fewer deaths every year.

One caution on the source for these figures. The 2004 Norwegian review behind them disclosed that one author worked for the country's largest margarine maker and another received its research funding. The supply and mortality figures come from national statistics, not from that company.

08 · Finland, 1972–2012

North Karelia did it on purpose

In the 1960s, men in North Karelia, in eastern Finland, had among the highest rates of heart disease in the world. In 1972 the region asked for help, and a young doctor, Pekka Puska, led a project that changed what people ate and smoked, with no war and no ration book.

−82%Deaths from coronary heart disease among North Karelian men aged 35 to 64, from 643 to 118 per 100,000 a year, between the early 1970s and 2012. Among women the fall was 84 percent.

Nobody went hungry. People kept eating; they ate differently and smoked less. This is the clean version of the experiment Norway ran by accident.

09 · Canada, 1942–1952

Canada ran it on children

While Norway lived on coupons, Canada's government was running food experiments of its own, and it chose its subjects. The record surfaced only in 2013, through the historian Ian Mosby.

When the story broke in July 2013, a spokesperson for the Aboriginal Affairs minister called it "abhorrent and completely unacceptable", if true, and pointed to the 2008 residential schools apology. There has been no separate inquiry into the experiments.

Norway's ration was a wartime hardship shared by everyone. Canada's was a design. The plate in this chapter is blank because the children were never pictured in the record that measured them. Canada also funded the sensory-deprivation research told in Contract X-38, on its own people, and held no inquiry into that either.

10 · The answer

Less, or different?

Put the whole record side by side and an answer comes out.

What eating less explains

  • A little weight loss, a little lower blood pressure
  • Part of Norway's fast dip
  • Not Britain, which ate less and showed no clear fall
  • Not the Hunger Winter, where starvation raised heart risk

What eating and living differently explains

  • The fast fall in clotting: more fish, far less tobacco
  • Britain's missing dip: more tobacco, not less
  • The twenty-year climb as margarine and milk fat doubled
  • The halving after 1970, and North Karelia's 82 percent, with no ration at all

The war did not show that we eat three times too much. It showed that what is on the plate, and what is in the pipe beside it, decides more than how much.

In the short run, the wartime dip came mostly from things that act within months: tobacco, fish, blood pressure, a little less weight. Some of the recorded dip was an artefact of how deaths were counted. In the long run, Norway's rise and fall tracked the fat on the table and the cigarettes in people's hands, not the number of calories. Eating less and eating differently are two different interventions. The record from occupied Norway supports eating differently.

Pass it on

Keep the record moving

Share the explainer

Most people have heard that rationing was good for the heart. Fewer know which part of it was.

Read the record

The record

  1. Strøm A, Jensen RA. Mortality from circulatory diseases in Norway 1940–1945. The Lancet, 1951
  2. Gogstad AC. Helsetilstanden under okkupasjonsårene: dødelighet. Tidsskrift for Den norske legeforening, 1990
  3. Pedersen JI, Tverdal A, Kirkhus B. Kostendringer og dødelighetsutvikling av hjerte- og karsykdommer i Norge. Tidsskrift for Den norske legeforening, 2004
  4. Bønaa KH. Coronary heart disease mortality. Tidsskrift for Den norske legeforening, 2011
  5. Vadset Å. Tobakksdyrking under 2. verdenskrig. Bergen Byarkiv
  6. Bang HO, Dyerberg J. Personal reflections on the incidence of ischaemic heart disease in Oslo during the Second World War. Acta Medica Scandinavica, 1981
  7. Burr ML et al. Diet and reinfarction trial (DART). The Lancet, 1989
  8. Barker DJ, Osmond C. Diet and coronary heart disease in England and Wales during and after the second world war. Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health, 1986
  9. Adams R, de Zwarte I. Rationing in Britain during World War II. University of Oxford, 2020, reproducing Zweiniger-Bargielowska, Austerity in Britain
  10. Forey B et al. International Smoking Statistics: United Kingdom. P N Lee Statistics and Computing, 2016
  11. Hindhede M. The effect of food restriction during war on mortality in Copenhagen. JAMA, 1920
  12. Vorstenbosch T et al. Famine food of vegetal origin consumed in the Netherlands during World War II. Journal of Ethnobiology and Ethnomedicine, 2017
  13. Ekamper P et al. War-related excess mortality in The Netherlands, 1944–45. Historical Methods, 2017
  14. Roseboom TJ et al. Coronary heart disease after prenatal exposure to the Dutch famine, 1944–45. Heart, 2000
  15. Norsk Folkemuseum. 1950-tallet: Midt i et århundre
  16. Nylenna M. Paul Owren, Christopher Bjerkelund and the dawn of controlled trials in Norway. Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine, 2024
  17. Puska P et al. Changes in premature deaths in Finland. Bulletin of the World Health Organization, 1998
  18. Jousilahti P et al. 40-Year CHD mortality trends: the North Karelia Project experience. Global Heart, 2016
  19. Vartiainen E et al. Changes in serum cholesterol and diet in North Karelia and all Finland. Global Heart, 2016
  20. Mosby I. Administering Colonial Science: nutrition research and human biomedical experimentation in Aboriginal communities and residential schools, 1942–1952. Histoire sociale / Social History, 2013
  21. Canadian Press via CBC News. Hungry aboriginal people used in bureaucrats' experiments, July 16, 2013

The plates on this page are engraved illustrations. They carry no evidence; every figure rests on the sources above. This page is history, not medical advice.

Share

Share this card